For the first time ever, Mary Jo Buttafuoco tells her story in her own words. In May 1992, outside her Long Island home, Mary Jo was shot in the head by 17-year-old Amy Fisher - the mistress of her husband, Joey Buttafuoco.
Trailer
Cast
Dillon Casey
Joey Buttafuoco
ED
Easten Dacosta
Paul Buttafuoco
PD
Paisley Dacosta
Jessica Buttafuoco
Wesla Wong
News Reporter
Michael Esposito II
Young Adult Paul Buttafuoco
Carly Fawcett
Eileen
Shay Galor
Nosy Woman
Chardonnay Hanna
Young Adult Jessie
Maddy Hillis
Amy Fisher
Chloe Lanier
Mary Jo Buttafuoco
Indy Lesage
Steven
Curtis Lovell
Hollywood Exec
Annaston Munro
High School Mary Jo
Dayleigh Nelson
Lead Cop
Jayden Oniah
Young boy
Thane Ramsay
High School Joey
Tiffany Rice
Maternity Nurse
Vincent Ross
ER Doctor
You Might Also Like
Biography6.8
I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco
Biography5.2
From Straight A's to XXX
Biography5.7
Nelly
Biography6.8
Bombshell
Biography8.3
Wu-Tang: An American Saga
Biography7.3
WeCrashed
Biography7.7
Five Days at Memorial
Biography7.5
The Dropout
Crime6.7
All the Queen's Men
Drama5.9
Beauty in Black
Crime7.9
The Wife
Crime8.5
Snowfall
Biography7.1
Hello Bachhon
Biography8.6
Veneno
Biography7.3
"Immigrant"
Biography7.2
A Very Royal Scandal
Biography6.4
Untameable
Biography7.9
Nothing Gold Can Stay
Biography7.5
Halston
Biography8.3
Feud: Bette and Joan
Biography8.3
Julia
Biography6.8
The Dreamer - Becoming Karen Blixen
Biography7.5
The Dropout
Biography6.0
Angelyne
Comments
2 Comments
Richardene SamuelsFeb 25, 2026
MiniTVFeb 25, 2026