Elizabeth Pedroza (Curtis) has been crushing on the hottest guy in her University, John Eduque Jr. (Manzano). She remains unnoticed because she's just an ordinary girl who ordinarily adores John's type, a hunky, athletic, popular honor student. But she knows that there's more to him than meets the eyes, that that distinct feature makes her love him even more. Through the years, Elizabeth strives and becomes the dream girl of every guy on the planet: independent, beautiful, sophisticated, sweet, and loving--no longer the ordinary college student. But she still loves only John, and tons of pictures of him decorate her new condominium. When she reads in the news that John Eduque has died, she immediately assumes it's "her John." She goes to the funeral dressed in black, complete with black veil, cries her lungs out in front of the casket, and saying everything she should have said when he was alive. When she finally notices that the deceased is John Eduque Sr., "her John"'s father, and the casket is surrounded by horrified mourners, she runs for her life in total mortification. Now that John and his vicious mother (Domingo) are on the lookout for her, believing that she was John Sr.'s mistress, what could happen to Elizabeth's lifelong dream of becoming John's one and only love?